Famous Tank Battles

The Saucer and the Blockhouse bring the battle of El Alamein down to its most human and disturbing level. By the end of October 1942, the Australians in the northern sector were pushing toward the coast road, and the fighting around the railway line west of Tel el Eisa had become a struggle of infantry, tanks, anti-tank guns, and exhaustion. In that fighting, a shallow area near the road and railway became known as the Saucer, because of the way it seemed to hold men under observation and fire. Inside it stood a low concrete building, the Blockhouse, first used by the Germans as a medical post and then transformed into an improvised aid station for wounded men of both sides. Its story matters because it shows that even in mechanized war, humanity and terror could occupy the same few rooms.

If you would like to move beyond the podcast, you can see my available books at Military Author dot me. And at Trackpads dot com, you will find magazines and galleries with hundreds of thousands of photos and videos to explore.

The plan that led to the Saucer was ambitious. Major General Leslie Morshead, commander of the 9th Australian Division, wanted to push north and threaten the enemy defenses around the coast. The 2/32nd Battalion was to establish a firm base near the railway and main road. From that base, the exhausted 2/24th and 2/48th Battalions were to attack eastward toward strong German positions such as Thompson’s Post and Ring Contour 25. The 2/3rd Pioneer Battalion, an infantry-capable unit trained for construction and field work, was then to drive north toward the coast and help cut off enemy troops still holding the coastal defenses. On paper, it was a way to trap part of the Axis line. In practice, it became one of the ugliest fights of the battle.

The 2/32nd reached its objectives and captured the building that would become the Blockhouse. It was a long, low concrete structure near the railway, originally associated with railway work rather than war. By the time the Australians arrived, it had been used as a German casualty station. German doctors and orderlies were still there with wounded men and medical equipment. Australian medical officers soon took over the space as a regimental aid post, but the German medical personnel did not simply vanish from the story. They helped treat casualties, and for a time the building became an extraordinary place where enemies worked side by side because wounded men kept arriving faster than the battle could be understood.

Outside the Blockhouse, the attack was going badly for the battalions pushing east. The 2/24th and 2/48th had already been fighting for days and were reduced in strength before the operation began. They moved forward through fire, confusion, and defended ground where the enemy remained alert and dangerous. Machine guns, mortars, mines, and anti-tank weapons broke up the assault. Positions that reports suggested might be weak proved very much occupied. By dawn, the battalions had suffered appalling losses and had to pull back toward the firm base rather than be destroyed. What had been intended as a bold move against the rear of the enemy defenses became a desperate withdrawal through a landscape filling with wounded men.

The Saucer took shape as dawn revealed the Australians’ situation. The men were clustered around a few key points: the Blockhouse, a gap blown through the railway embankment, and Barrel Hill, a small ridge north of the railway. The area was roughly a pocket, exposed to observation from several directions. German observers could look into it, and German commanders understood that it was too dangerous to leave in Australian hands. It threatened the road and railway and created the possibility that Axis troops in the coastal sector might be cut off. The Australians inside it therefore had to defend a position that was both valuable and exposed. It was not a comfortable lodgment. It was a target.

The Blockhouse became the medical heart of this pocket. Wounded Australians were carried or helped there, and wounded Germans were treated there as well. Medical officers worked in crowded rooms, with men lying inside and outside the building. Stretcher-bearers moved through fire to collect casualties, and their work was as dangerous as any assault. A wounded man left in the open could die before the tactical situation made sense to anyone. The medical effort was not separate from the battle, because keeping wounded men alive required routes, courage, orderlies, dressings, water, and the willingness to move through ground still being shelled. The Blockhouse was an aid post, but it stood inside a battlefield rather than behind one.

The fighting around the Saucer soon became a combined-arms crisis. German tanks and infantry pressed toward the pocket, while artillery and mortars hit the ground around it. British Valentine tanks came forward to support the Australians, and anti-tank guns were brought into action wherever they could be sited. The defenders needed every weapon they could get because infantry alone could not stop tanks in open desert. At the same time, tanks could not maneuver freely through the mines, tracks, embankments, and crowded ground around the railway. The battle was not a clean armored clash. It was a cramped struggle in which tanks, anti-tank guns, artillery, infantry, and medical evacuation all collided within the same small space.

The railway embankment became both obstacle and shelter. Engineers had to create crossings so vehicles could pass, sometimes without the tools they expected and under fire from enemy weapons. The embankment could shield men from one direction while exposing them from another. It also shaped movement, because vehicles and stretcher parties had to find places where they could cross or pass along it. This is another reminder that armored warfare is governed by small physical facts. A bank of earth, a blocked crossing, or a disabled vehicle can shape the movement of tanks and supply trucks as surely as a commander’s order. At the Saucer, the battle depended on whether routes could be made and kept alive under observation.

The relief of exhausted units was one of the most dangerous tasks of the fight. By the end of 31 October, the 2/24th and 2/48th were too depleted to keep carrying the defense in the Saucer. Morshead decided to replace them with fresher battalions, including the 2/43rd and 2/28th. Relief in darkness is always difficult, but relief in a pocket under threat is worse. Incoming units had to find positions, understand a confused layout, and dig in on ground they had not reconnoitered properly. Outgoing survivors had to get out without opening a gap. The fact that the changeover succeeded was not a small administrative detail. It was one of the conditions that allowed the northern pressure to continue.

On 1 November, the Germans attacked again, believing that the force around the Blockhouse was badly depleted. In one sense, that belief was reasonable, because the earlier battalions had been almost worn out. What the Germans did not fully appreciate was that fresh troops had taken over during the night. Tanks and infantry attacked repeatedly, supported by fire from several directions, but the Australian defense held. Anti-tank guns, artillery, infantry weapons, and the stubborn use of ground broke up the assaults. The fighting continued into the night, and by the time it faded, another storm had begun farther south. Operation Supercharge, the renewed breakthrough effort, was opening while the Saucer still held.

The Blockhouse’s humanity should not be exaggerated into a sentimental story that softens the battle. Shells hit near it and at times into it. Ambulances and stretcher parties were in danger. Men died before they could be treated, and others survived only because medical personnel worked under conditions that would have overwhelmed a normal hospital. German and Australian medical staff cooperating did not cancel the violence around them. It made the violence clearer, because it showed that the men being brought in were bodies in pain before they were symbols of any army. The Blockhouse was an oasis only in a narrow and fragile sense. It was surrounded by fire, fear, and tactical necessity.

For armored warfare, the Saucer teaches a lesson that is easy to miss. The decisive breakthrough of El Alamein depended partly on places where tanks were not free to move and infantry could barely hold. By tying down German attention in the north, the Australians helped create the conditions for the main blow of Supercharge. By holding the Saucer, they threatened the coast road and forced Rommel to keep spending strength in a sector that could not be ignored. British armor, artillery, anti-tank guns, and infantry all had roles, but the key achievement was endurance. The defenders did not have to destroy the Axis army at the Saucer. They had to keep it worried, delayed, and committed for one more crucial day.

The Saucer and the Blockhouse deserve to be remembered together because they reveal two truths at once. The Saucer shows the battlefield as a trap of observation, mines, tanks, guns, and exposed infantry. The Blockhouse shows the same battlefield as a place where doctors, orderlies, stretcher-bearers, and wounded men struggled to preserve life amid destruction. Neither truth cancels the other. El Alamein was a victory of preparation, logistics, artillery, engineers, infantry, armor, and air power, but it was also a victory paid for by men crowded into shallow ground and carried into a concrete building by the railway. When Supercharge began, the northern sector had done its work. The Saucer had held, and the Blockhouse had become one of the battle’s most painful reminders of what holding meant.